The Pie Store in Montclair, NJ
Apple pie 24 — illustrative photo
Slice of apple pie 2 — illustrative photo
Small slice of molasses shoofly pie 2022 — illustrative photo

The Pie Store

Pie shop in Montclair, NJ 07043: opening hours, location and what to order.

Pie shop Hours listed
Get directions (973) 744-4424 See the menu

Opening hours

 
Eastern Time

Checking hours…

MondayClosed
Tuesday11 AM – 5 PM
Wednesday11 AM – 5 PM
Thursday11 AM – 5 PM
Friday11 AM – 5 PM
Saturday11 AM – 5 PM
Sunday11 AM – 3 PM

34 hours a week across 6 days. Holiday hours may differ.

Tap for directions

100 Watchung Avenue, Montclair, NJ 07043

Google Maps Apple Maps Waze Bing Maps
Address100 Watchung Avenue, Montclair, NJ 07043
Phone(973) 744-4424
StylePie shop
Time zoneEastern Time
From city center1.1 mi north

About The Pie Store

The Pie Store is a pie shop at 100 Watchung Avenue, 1.1 mi north of the Montclair city center.

Montclair has 29 places on our map that bake or sell fresh pastry, and this is one of them, which works out to one bakery per 1,416 residents. The closest neighbour on our map is Sunrise Bagels, less than 0.1 mi away.

The Pie Store opens as early as 11 AM and stays open until 5 PM on its longest day, for about 34 hours across 6 days a week. It keeps weekend hours on both Saturday and Sunday.

What to order

Typical items at a pie shop like this one — the bakery's own selection may differ.

Full menu

Fruit pies

  • Cherry lattice pieTart red cherries thickened into a glossy filling beneath a woven lattice crust that bakes up crisp and golden.
  • Blueberry pieJuicy blueberries with lemon zest and a hint of cinnamon, bubbling up through vents in the flaky top crust.
  • Fresh peach pieSummer peaches sliced thick and baked with a touch of brown sugar and vanilla until soft and syrupy.
  • Strawberry rhubarb pieSweet strawberries balanced by tart rhubarb in a pink, jammy filling; a short-season spring favorite.

Cream & custard pies

  • Lemon meringue pieSharp lemon filling capped with a tall, sweet meringue toasted until the peaks turn golden brown.
  • Chocolate cream pieCooked chocolate pudding filling, smooth and dense, chilled in a cookie crumb crust with whipped topping.
  • Butterscotch cream pieBrown sugar and butter custard with a deep caramel flavor, topped with lightly sweetened whipped cream.
  • Coconut cream pieRich coconut custard in a baked crust, topped with whipped cream and toasted coconut flakes.

Southern & heritage pies

  • Classic pecan pieToasted pecan halves set in a gooey brown sugar and corn syrup filling inside a buttery crust.
  • Chocolate bourbon pecanPecan pie enriched with dark chocolate chunks and a splash of bourbon for depth and warmth.
  • Sweet potato pieSmooth, spiced custard of roasted sweet potato, brown sugar and nutmeg; lighter and earthier than pumpkin.
  • Buttermilk chess pieSimple Southern custard of eggs, sugar, butter and buttermilk, baked until the top caramelizes into a thin crust.

Typical busy times

5 AM9 AM1 PM5 PM10 PM

Estimated from the opening hours and typical bakery traffic — not live data.

When to go

  • Weekday mornings are usually the rush, peaking around Noon.
  • For the widest choice, arrive within the first hour after opening — popular items can sell out by early afternoon.
  • The last hour before closing tends to be quiet, and some bakeries discount day-old bread then.
Full hours

Photos

All photos
The Pie Store in Montclair, NJ
The Pie Store
Apple pie 24 — illustrative photo
Illustrative photo
Slice of apple pie 2 — illustrative photo
Illustrative photo
Small slice of molasses shoofly pie 2022 — illustrative photo
Illustrative photo

Visitor reviews

Write a review
No reviews yet. Been to The Pie Store? Your review helps other people decide — be the first to write one.

Questions about The Pie Store

What are The Pie Store's hours?
The Pie Store's listed hours are Mon: Closed; Tue–Sat: 11 AM – 5 PM; Sun: 11 AM – 3 PM. Holiday hours can differ.
Is The Pie Store open on Sunday?
Yes. On Sundays it is open 11 AM – 3 PM.
What time does The Pie Store open in the morning?
The earliest listed opening time is 11 AM on Tuesday.
Where is The Pie Store located?
The Pie Store is at 100 Watchung Avenue, Montclair, NJ 07043. Tap the map on this page to open turn-by-turn directions.
What is the phone number for The Pie Store?
The listed phone number is (973) 744-4424.
What should I order at The Pie Store?
As a pie shop, typical picks include Cherry lattice pie, Blueberry pie, Lemon meringue pie, and Chocolate cream pie. See the full menu page for more.
What other bakeries are near The Pie Store?
Nearby options include Sunrise Bagels (less than 0.1 mi), Beyond the Bagel (0.7 mi), and Mattarello Bakery & Cafe (0.7 mi).

Bakeries near The Pie Store

Sunrise Bagels
Sunrise Bagels29 Watchung Plaza, Montclair
less than 0.1 mi awayBagel shop
Beyond the Bagel
Beyond the Bagel219 Bellevue Ave, Montclair
0.7 mi awayBagel shop
Mattarello Bakery & Cafe
Mattarello Bakery & Cafe254 Bellevue Ave, Montclair
0.7 mi awayItalian bakery
Somedays Bakery - Montclair
Somedays Bakery - Montclair260 Bellevue Ave, Montclair
0.7 mi awayBakery
Manhattan Bagel
Manhattan Bagel250 Bellevue Ave, Montclair
0.7 mi awayBagel shop
The Little Daisy Bake Shop
The Little Daisy Bake Shop622 Valley Rd, Montclair
0.8 mi awayBakery
Hot Bagels Abroad
Hot Bagels Abroad150 Valley Rd Ste A, Montclair
0.8 mi awayBagel shop
Montclair Bread Company
Montclair Bread Company16 Label St, Montclair
0.9 mi awayArtisan bread bakery
All bakeries in Montclair29 bakeries on one map Pie ShopsFind more near you Open right nowBakeries open at this moment near you